panhandling

1103-september23-2005
saturday night, i went out with nick, phil, and ken. we went down to harvard/comm after having a couple of drinks in my apartment. i was fairly buzzed.

i had to stop at the atm for a minute, and there were 3-4 people sitting on the sidewalk just to the right of the atm entrance. "spare change?" one asked us. i said i didn't have anything. everyone else ignored them.

"maybe on the way out?"
"i'll see what i can do"

now, atms spit out twenty dollar bills. occasionally tens. or in vegas, hundreds. they do not spit out quarters or singles. i did have a few dollars on me, however, and after getting some money from the atm, i thought about it, and took out a dollar. i asked if anyone else wanted to give money to that guy outside. i have no idea if phil or ken said anything (as i mentioned, i was buzzed at the time) but nick did say that he wasn't a fan of giving money to homeless people.

anyways, we went out, i gave the man a dollar, he told me he loved me, i might have returned the love, and we went on our way.

nick told me that he once gave money to someone who was homeless, and that he later saw that guy in a restaurant he was working in getting a drink.

i think i started singing "mr. wendell" and then told him that homeless people need alcohol way more than any of us did. he accepted that, but then we started talking about arrested development (the band, not the show).

so anyways, i wasn't sober and i gave the guy a buck.

big deal.

freshman year one time, jen and i went to dinner in porter square and after dinner we were walking around and a guy asked me for some money. i told him i didn't have any, and he told me that he was homeless and he had to sleep on the streets that night and he just wanted enough money to buy a pack of cigarettes. now, maybe i did this because i was in front of jen or whatever, but i gave that guy a $5.

i just had a huge sushi meal. this guy wanted $5 so he could have a pack of smokes for the night... or maybe he wanted $5 for crack. or malt liquor. who gives a shit? the guy needed $5, and that $5 would make him (temporarily) much happier than it would make me. or at least, that's what i figured right then.

anyways, i think overall i'm pretty comfortable occasionally giving money to homeless people. i'm fine with giving a dollar regularly i think, and $5 in the extreme situation where the guy will engage me in conversations about angela lansbury (i vaguely recall this happening, but i don't remember the details).

on the drive in to work every day, there is at least one person who stands in the median near a stoplight, holding a sign up asking for help to all the commuters going into and out of alewife. i always want to pull down the window and give a dollar. or some change. or something. but i never do. i do the awkward 'look-away-but-not-really' when they walk by my car, and i always am half-pulling towards yelling "hey, here's a dollar... no in fact, naw, here's two"

i know i'm going to see that person for at least a few more days. am i going to give this person $20-$30 over the course of a month just because they are always there? am i going to feel obligated every single time?

i really think i should feel that way. i think that this is the right thing to do. i should give them $20-$30 over the course of a month. helping another person is definitely worth that trivial amount of money.

so i guess on monday, if i'm stopped and there is a person at that median, i will be giving them a dollar or some change or something. anything to help them get through the night.

comments

re: comment

from: jen (2005-09-23 11:19:30)

i remember being astounded that niv did that, especially since the guy said he was going to buy cigarettes with it, while i thought the money should better be used for a sandwich or whathaveyou. but i think differently now that i'm earning my own money, because i know there are wholly inconsequential things -like an expensive coffee or whatever- that i'll drop way more than 50 cents or a dollar on because they're nice things to have, so giving someone you don't know some money just seems fine and right.

AND, niv and i were discussing angela lansbury before he approached us (why?) and he simply interjected that he hoped i wasn't a lesbian, especially with regard to angela lansbury.

re: boston has the most privileged homeless people in the world

from: z (2005-09-23 11:38:34)

its really funny that you picked that guy at alewife as your example becuase he is THE reason i stopped giving money to homeless people (assuming he is the same person that was there when i was in college, and for the sake of my argument lets)

you take a run of the mill vagrant. skinny, dirty, clearly hasn't showered in maybe ever, clearly doesn't take care of himself because he clearly can't. in otherwords, clearly homeless. and i'm with you. 100%. these are the guys that can't do anything else because they are crazy or sick or handicapped in some way mentally, phsycially, or possbily even just socially, and literally are incapable of taking care of themselves. they deserve help, and $30 a month is nothing.

that guy at alewife, however, is a different story. him, along with the panhandlers in the T stations near colleges. he's been there for six years. he's overweight. he's a little scraggly but he obviously has the ability to clean himself. look at his feet. i swear to god i saw him wearing brand new timberlands once. these guys do this shit for a living. they make money just by taking it from people like you, who have a conscience and want to share their good fortune.

conservatively, that light goes red around 15 times in an hour. if he makes a dollar, on average, every time that light goes red, he's pulling down $15/hr. TAX FREE. its a modest living, but it is a living, and it is at your expense.

like i said i agree with you on principal, but i think you have to be careful about how and who help. buy food and give them the food, and only if they clearly need help. or something along those lines. but don't enable them by giving them something for nothing.

all that being said
i paid a guy $10 to leave me and my friends alone one drunken night
so i probably shouldn't talk

re: things change

from: niv (2005-09-23 11:44:14)

i drive by there every day now. i used to, then i moved to brighton and i stopped, but since changing jobs again i'm back at that alewife exchange getting on to route 2. and the person has changed about once every 4-5 days. there's one person there for a little while, then someone new, then someone new.

i see your point - some people are frauds looking for handouts.

but this is america. innocent until proven guilty!

re: that's where the money's at

from: Darryl (2005-09-23 20:27:04)

I work in a big city and I see guys out there looking for change all the time in the same spots. I never give them anything, because they're never creative enough to warrent my attention.

A while ago (maybe 2 or 3 years) the globe and mail sent out a reporter to 'act' homeless for a week. While homeless, he pulled in an average of $200/day and met a few people who also did the same - and at the end of the day they went home to their nice apartments.

I know they're not all like that, but it's scary to know that people are like that.

There are some days (ok, most) that I look like a bum. Maybe if I had the balls to ask for change I could get my daily expenses paid for.

re: remember that guy?

from: ken (2005-09-26 15:19:39)

Niv, you may or may not remember him but Parker, Thad and Phil should.. remember when I was moving out of 38, trying to find someone to sublet my room and the musician guy showed up? He basically said 'I have no money but I can make a few hundred dollars a day panhandling while playing guitar at such and such a spot in boston no problem'. Needless to say he was a little sketchy and he didnt get the room but it could be people like you that he's banking on.

re: two things

from: niv (2005-09-26 15:52:08)

well 1, i do remember that, but he's at least playing guitar. those guys have to, you know, ask the city to do that shit. and they sit there with piles of money in their guitar cases in front of them

two, the guy wasn't there today, oddly enough. so, my pledge was null and void.

 

name

email

website

save info?

comment title

comment

what is seven plus one? (in digits, please)
current time
September 7, 2008 12:34:02

please use html when creating links. click here if you do not know how to do this.